Kenton-Co-Courthouse
The Kenton County Courthouse in Covington. File photo | LINK nky

A Kenton County Circuit Court Judge dismissed a lawsuit against Maria Ante, a Kenton County judicial candidate, over allegations of not meeting the residency requirements needed to run for the seat.

Kenton County 6th Division Family Court Judicial candidate Ashley McNeese filed a 21-page lawsuit in Kenton Circuit Court last month, alleging her opponent Ante didn’t meet the residency requirement. McNeese wanted Ante’s name stripped from the ballot as a result.

The lawsuit alleged that Ante wasn’t a resident of Kenton County on or before Jan. 1, 2021, which made her ineligible to run for judge in Kenton County. It claims Ante lived in Boone County until October 2021, when she purchased a home in Villa Hills, which is in Kenton County.

The Kentucky Constitution requires that a family court judge reside in the district they will serve for at least two years before running for office.

McNeese argued that this makes Ante ineligible to run for the position, an eight-year term that starts on Jan. 2, 2023. The election takes place on Nov. 8, 2022.

However, Circuit Court Judge Kathleen Lape said that the burden of proof was on McNeese to show that Ante didn’t live in Kenton County before Jan. 2, 2021, and McNeese didn’t provide that evidence.

“Petitioner (McNeese) offered no evidence of the actual date that Ante moved to Kenton County,” Lape said in her judgment.

Further, Lape said that the documents submitted by McNeese show that there is just a timeframe for Ante’s move, but she didn’t offer testimony from neighbors or other credible witnesses.

“We never let this distraction slow us down,” Ante said in a statement. “I know the law and had absolutely no doubt our legal system would reaffirm that. I’m thrilled to keep advocating for children and families every day. Kenton County…I see you, I hear you, and I’m here to keep working.”

McNeese’s attorney, Steve Megerle, said in a statement that McNeese will not be appealing and instead is focusing on sharing her qualifications as a former judicial clerk and longtime prosecutor with voters.

“Ante was a carpet bagger having two houses, one in Boone, and then  moving into her mom and dad’s house sometime after Christmas 2020,” Megerle said. “The court believed ‘biased’ family members over the documentary evidence proving significant water usage indicative of living in Boone County at the same time. We wanted a judge to decide, and a decision was made. Instead of appealing,  Ashley McNeese chose to focus on the voters and sharing her qualifications as a former judicial clerk and longtime prosecutor holding dead beat dads accountable, then Maria Ante, who hurriedly moved a family of 4 into mom and dad’s house to barely qualify to run for a family court judgeship affecting thousands of families and children each and every day.”

Mark Payne is the government and politics reporter for LINK nky. Email him at mpayne@linknky.com. Twitter.